Montreal Sushi Crisis Part II

It's time to sound the alarm. The crisis I hoped to avoid is indeed upon us. But, and there's always a but, the situation isn't as dire as I had originally predicted. Phew. Still, the quest for sushi in Montreal that is both high in quality and affordable, remains just that – a quest.

The reason we can relax a tad and avoid an Armageddon scenario is thanks to a little place on Parc Ave. called Bistro Isakaya. My parents found out about Isakaya through their friends at La Mer, who informed them the restaurant's Japanese born sushi chef/owner purchases only the best. Decor-wise, Isakaya isn't particularly exciting on the eyes and the service is good, not great. But if the sashimi is fresh, I'm a happy camper and it's definitely fresh here. I'm not sure when they have it, but if king salmon sashimi happens to be available, you must try it. Plus, the maki rolls are simple – i.e. none of that mango, curry, cream cheese crap that screams of inauthenticity. My favourite is the Isakaya roll featuring salmon, crab meat, white fish, tobiko and cucumber, however, classics like the spider with soft shell crab, salmon kamikaze and California are also excellent. And though I'm not the biggest lobster fan, my friends who tried Isakaya's lobster roll had nothing but positive accolades for it.

Maki and sashimi at Bistro Isakaya 

Appetizer wise, the dishes are also simple yet tasty. Standout apps include the tuna cocktail and the ultra light fried eggplant in bonito broth. Isakaya also does lunch and it's cheap, cheap cheap which is why I'll let it slide that there aren't plenty of options to choose from. Oh, and speaking of cheap, considering the quality of the fish, a dinner for one at Isakya without alcohol can easily cost under $35. Are you out the door and in the car yet?

Fried eggplant in bonito broth at Bistro Isakaya

But, oh, there it is again, I still think Bishoku in its heyday (before new management and chefs took over) was better than Isakaya. The freshness factor is virtually equal at both, however, I simply preferred Bishoku's slightly more inventive appetizers, maki rolls and the service was undoubtedly superior. I do think liking one over the other comes down to a matter of tastes and we all know how tastes can vary, so I'll let you decide for yourselves. This is intended for the people who knew Bishoku before the "changes" because I don't suggest you go there now. Sadly, it hasn't gotten better. Let's leave it at that because it's a sensitive subject.

I also returned to 5 Saisons which reopened late September after a fire related closing. 5 Saisons delivers (within the NDG/Westmount areas), so there's a big brownie point right there. It's also a BYOB which merits at least 3 brownie points if not more. The restaurant's fare ranks quite well on the freshness and taste scale, but I'm not exaggerating when I say it wasn't easy finding maki rolls that weren't "contaminated" with fruits or an abundance of tempura flakes. I find that extremely frustrating, albeit I am an easily frustrated gal. What's more, 5 Saisons is no cheaper than Isakaya, so unless I'm ordering takeout and need lots of wine to go with my sushi (hey, somedays can be really stressful), then I'm dragging my butt to Parc Ave.

The Te Quiero roll at 5 Saisons with spicy tuna, crispy tempura, cooked shrimp and avocado rolled in a soya bean leaf was too heavy on the sauce and tempura. 

Clearly a woman on a mission, I went to Sushi Yu Mi on Sherbrooke West as well. It's an adorable little spot that's designed mainly for takeout orders. The staff was friendly and my order of maki rolls was completed quickly and the cost was very reasonable. Though I can't put my finger on exactly what it was, I can say that something felt just slightly off. Don't get me wrong, it was good and I'd like to give it a second chance, yet there was a taste to certain rolls that just didn't jive with my palette.

Kaizen was another place I visited on my search for sushi greatness only to find sushi suckiness of the highest degree. It was bad, and when I say bad I mean BAD as in awful, as in STAY THE HELL AWAY. Are we clear? My intention isn't to insult anyone, but I feel fortunate to have walked out of there without food poisoning because the fish was the furthest thing from fresh. It's a shame because the service was top notch, the interior is beautiful and spacious, and Kaizen has one of the best wine lists in town. To be honest, it's also too expensive to even be on this list since my search is about quality and affordability, but I had to try it. I left Kaizen feeling robbed – it's totally overpriced, especially when you factor in the yuckiness. If you're willing to spend on sushi, go to Jun I. I raved about it in Montreal Sushi Crisis Part I and I have been back several times since and each meal was better than the last. Word of advice: if there's a roll of the month, do yourself a favor and order it – you won't regret it.

The seaweed salad was the only dish I enjoyed at Kaizen. 

Unfortunately, I didn't try Oishii Sushi, nor did I revisit Shodan or Tri Express. After all, I was beginning to fear mercury poisoning. Based on my memories, Shodan is a good bet, although for the price I suggest Jun I. As for Tri Express, I've only been once and it was at least five years ago. I do recall a superb meal that perhaps was a little too avant garde for me back then, though let me assure you this foodie has grown up. Okay so maybe I scared you a little too much at first, but I had to get your attention somehow. So there you have it my friends, now go and eat some sushi and share your thoughts with me.

The sashimi appetizer at Jun I